MARTIAN TREES

Theories
How to find the images
More info

 
 
THEORIES...
 

Interesting and strange images from the Mars Global Surveyor (MGS) appear to indicate plant life on the planet. One image shows what appear to be tree-shaped structures in the south polar region. Another image has dark spots that look like shrubs in a desert. It turns out that these shapes vary during the year, and change size and color depending on the season. They get larger and darker during the summer as would be expected by plants. This has led a Hungarian research team (Institute for Advanced Study, Budapest) to conclude that may be evidence of living organisms.

ORTHODOX: The official NASA story is that the tree-like images are actually "sand dunes topped with melting frost." Given that the temperature on the surface is -150 C, they are not believed to be plants. Also, according to an article in SPACE.com, a NASA Mars Exploration Program Scientist James Garvin did not feel that the evidence was "adequate to draw definitive conclusions about whether biological processes were involved in their origin". Other viewpoints include "bizarre geology" and "frosting-defrosting" processes. Regarding the "shrublike images," the Malin Space Science Systems website claims that they are also "defrosting sand dunes."

ALTERNATIVE: The Hungarian team believes that the shrubby looking "dark dune spots" may be plant-like organisms that are under a layer of ice in the winter and emerge when the ice melts in the summer.

Sir Arthur C. Clarke, (image, right, courtesy of Popular Science) has jumped into the fray in a June 2001 interview noting that these images, which he thinks look like Banyan trees, support his belief in life on Mars. The author of 2001 joked "I'm now convinced that Mars is inhabited by a race of demented landscape gardeners."
JIMBO's VIEW: The tree picture appears to show that there is a shadow cast on each "tree" by the sun, the shadow being roughly 300 meters, somewhat independent of the width of the object. Therefore, they can not be simply spots of frost, although since the sun is low in the sky (about 1 hour of true solar time according to the data of the tree image), it is possible that these objects are not very tall. I don't like the Banyan tree theory, because some of them would have to be 1.5 km wide, according to the resolution of the image. I also find curious a tree that would look like a crystal formation from above. The original NASA explanation doesn't seem to fit either since many of the objects in the upper part of the image are only 20 meters wide or so, and it doesn't make much sense that a large number of dunes just happened to only have a 20 meter top poking through after the frost melts. So, I'm thinking some sort of weird patch of vegitation covered in ice which melts in patterns radially outwards from the center. As for the cold temps, some earthbound plants are known to be very hardy. For example, redosier dogwood stems can survive temperatures slightly colder than 300 degrees below zero.
 
HOW TO FIND the images from the original MGS charts...
 
1. Go to the Malin Space Science Systems web site. Click on the images link (or go directly here.)
2. Click on the "MO7 through M12, September 1999 - February 2000" link (or go directly here.)
3. You'll see a map like the one shown below in Figure 1. Click on the southern pole MC-30: Mare Australe. See red arrow in Figure 1 for location of segment.
 

Figure 1
 
4. You'll see a detailed map like the one shown below in Figure 2. At about a third of the way from the south pole to the right edge of the picture (82.02°S, 284.38°W), click on http://www.msss.com/moc_gallery/m07_m12/resolve/resolve_Mare_Australe_SP-162.html (the mouseover will say ("click here to select footprints in the area 82.0° to 81.0°S, 270.0° to 285.0°W.")) See red arrow in Figure 2 for location of link.
 

Figure 2
 
5. Since there are close or overlapping links in this region, the page that opens will give several options. Select Image ID M08-04688 (or click here to go directly to it).
6. Select one of the "full-size image" links.
7. The trees are in the upper right part of the image.
 
MORE INFO ...